WorkbenchThe target a2b (the diamond) lies on the segment joining the sources a3 and b3, so it can be built. Press “Pick the target” and try another target; then change the sources to other points.
Loading figure…
What this move does
The two sides of an inequality to be proved are often polynomials of the same degree, for example
a3+b3+c3≥a2b+b2c+c2a(a,b,c≥0).
The mean inequality says: the geometric mean of a few numbers (built from their product) is at most their arithmetic mean. Think of each term as its vector of exponents; the exponents of the geometric mean are then the average of the exponents. So:
For each term on the small side (a target), find a few terms on the big side (sources) such that the target's exponents are a weighted average of the sources' exponents. In the exponent triangle: the target lies in the region spanned by the sources.
Find the weights wi and write the weighted mean inequality target≤∑wi⋅sourcei. With a common denominator, this is an ordinary n-term AM–GM (with some sources repeated).
Cycle a→b→c→a and add the three inequalities. Finally check the equality condition: all sources equal.
Predict first
To write a2b≤xa3+yb3 (with x+y=1), what should x be?
Choose an answer first; then you can see the result.
✓You predicted it!✗Look at the exponent of a: it is 2 on the left, and the “average exponent” on the right is 3x + 0·y.
Compare the exponents of a: 2=3x, so x=32 and y=31. Check with the exponent of b: 1=3⋅31 ✓.
This is just the three-term mean inequality a3+a3+b3≥33a6b3=3a2b.
Work through one
Example: prove a³ + b³ + c³ ≥ a²b + b²c + c²a, and its fourth-degree sibling
Step 1 / 7
Loading figure…
Where is the target?
The exponents of a2b are (2,1,0): on the bottom edge, near the a3 corner. The big side has only the three corners a3,b3,c3.
a2b≤?
a³ alone is not enough
Add b³
Add the cyclic versions
Equality
Degree four: a target inside the triangle
Add cyclically, done
The exponent triangle is more than a helper picture: it tells you directly which inequalities can be proved this way. If the target lies outside the sources' region, weighted AM–GM is powerless (and such an “inequality” is usually false in the first place).
When it fails
Break it
Counterexample lab: remove one condition
Conclusion: AM–GM bounds the target by the sources← still true?
abc sits right in the middle of the small triangle formed by a2b, b2c, c2a: abc≤31(a2b+b2c+c2a), which is just the three-term mean inequality.
Loading figure…
What about the other way round: bounding a3 by a2b, b2c, c2a? Move the target to a corner.
Loading figure…
a3 is outside the region, and the machine says “no”. This is not the method being too weak: with a=2, b=c=1 we get a2b+b2c+c2a=7 but a3+b3+c3=10, so “a2b+b2c+c2a≥a3+b3+c3” is simply false.
Practice
Exercise 1Basic
Write ab2≤xa3+yb3 (with x+y=1 and a,b≥0). What is x?
Hint · direction
Compare the exponents of a.
Hint · method
On the left, a has exponent 1; on the right the “average exponent” is 3x.
Hint · first step
3x=1.
Full solution
x=31 and y=32: ab2≤3a3+2b3, that is, a3+b3+b3≥3ab2.
Exercise 2Basic
Prove that a2+b2+c2≥ab+bc+ca for all real numbers a,b,c, and say when equality holds.
Hint · direction
The exponents (1,1,0) of ab lie exactly halfway between a2 and b2.
Hint · method
The two-term inequality 2x2+y2≥xy holds for all real numbers (it is equivalent to (x−y)2≥0).
Hint · first step
2a2+b2≥ab, 2b2+c2≥bc, 2c2+a2≥ca.
Full solution
Add the three inequalities. Equality needs a=b, b=c and c=a at once, that is, a=b=c.
Exercise 3Advanced
Let a,b,c≥0. Prove that a4+b4+c4≥a3b+b3c+c3a.
Hint · direction
Find a3b in the degree-4 triangle. Which edge is it on?
Hint · method
a3b lies between a4 and b4, a quarter of the way from a4.
Hint · first step
a3b≤43a4+41b4, that is, a4+a4+a4+b4≥4a3b.
Full solution
Cycling gives b3c≤43b4+41c4 and c3a≤43c4+41a4. Add the three: every fourth power on the right has coefficient 1. Equality holds if and only if a=b=c.
Exercise 4Challenge
Let x,y,z>0. Prove that yx+zy+xz≥3xyzx+y+z.
Hint · direction
Split the right side into three terms such as 3xyzx. Can each be built from a few terms on the left?
Hint · method
3xyzx=3yzx2. Which terms on the left multiply to yzx2?
Hint · first step
(yx)2⋅zy=yzx2, so 3xyzx≤31(yx+yx+zy).
Full solution
Cycling gives the other two: 3xyzy≤31(2zy+xz) and 3xyzz≤31(2xz+yx). Adding, the right side is exactly yx+zy+xz. Equality needs yx=zy=xz; their product is 1, so all three equal 1, that is, x=y=z.
Taking “half and half” as the weights without thinking
✗
The wrong step: a2b≤2a3+b3; adding the cyclic versions gives a2b+b2c+c2a≤a3+b3+c3.
What went wrong? Think first, then open
DiagnosisThe conclusion happens to be true, but the first step is false: with a=1, b=0.8 the left side is 0.8 and the right side is 21+0.512=0.756. On the right, the average exponent of a is 23+0=23, not 2: the two sides do not match up.
✓
The right step: Choose the weights so that the exponents match: the exponent of a is 2=3⋅32+0⋅31, so a2b≤32a3+31b3, that is, a3+a3+b3≥3a2b.
“Match the exponents first, then write the inequality”
Proving Inequalities with AM–GM ← → step · F full screen · Esc exit